I really don’t like Simchat Torah. It's my least favorite of all the holidays. While others spend this holiday in a drunken joyful haze, I usually spend it in the corner with broken tears. This was not always the case. As I child I loved Simchat Torah. I loved the bags of candy I received, the flags, the dancing, the tricks my brothers and I pulled on people. Simply put, no other holiday could match Simchat Torah. That all came crashing down one Simchat Torah when I was eleven years old.
Every Simchat Torah is a special occasion because everyone is supposed to receive an Aliyah (to get called up tothe Torah). It is a great honour and on Simchat Torah everyone in my synagogue (except for the women) gets called up, even the children. Seeing as I had not had my Bat Mitzvah yet, I was still considered a child according to Jewish Law. When I went up to receive my Aliyah, I was pushed away by one of the men and told I was too old. I was pushed off because I was a girl because none of the boys my age were kicked off. I ran back to the women’s section and cried to my mother. She turned around to me and said, “You go back up there, you’re still a child. You have every right to be there.” I persisted and pushed my way back up there and received my Aliyah, but I had lost my joy. I had lost my simcha for the holiday. That Simchat Torah was the last Aliyah I got.
The following years were not much better. I constantly strived to try and find that joy, that simcha again, but every year just became harder. I would try to go to other events but I landed up just sitting on the sidelines. Mostly, I would end the holiday wallowing in a corner with tears in my eyes. Basically, what I had learnt was that Simchat Torah is not a holiday for women and it's not a holiday for me.
I realized that finding my simcha was not to be through a quick fix of drunkenness or fake jubilation. I realized I would have to go far to find the simcha again. Far I went, to New York. New York's famed Simchat Torah's Upper West Side bash. The air there filled with music and warm Kiddushes. But I was still not content; I had come to New York for one reason.
I had this revelation during my years of study in university, where I had focused on contemporary Jewish issues. I realized that since I had lost my simcha because the Aliya had been taken away from me-to gain back my simcha I would take back the Aliyah. So on Simchat Torah day I would head over to Darchei Noam, the Partnership Minyan (an Orthodox service led by both men and women) on the Upper West Side to receive my first Aliyah post-Batmivah. The day started out early. I could barely sleep the night before, I was so excited. I was going to receive an Aliyah something that has been denied to women for so many years and had been denied to me for twelve years. I practiced my Hebrew name over and over again in my head. “ Sarah bat Zvi Jonatan v’ Chava Leah, Sarah bat Zvi Jonatan v’ Chava Leah, Sarah bat Zvi Jonatan v’ Chava Leah.” When I was going to be called up I was going to be ready. I got up quickly, got dressed and ran like I had never run to synagogue before, over to Darchei Noam, which is housed in the Abraham Joshua Heschel School.
As I walked in they were in the middle of Hakafot. The men were dancing on one side of the mechtiza with theTorah. The women were dancing on the other side of the mechitza with their Torah. Children were running in between the two groups, just like I used to do.
Then came the Aliyot. Unlike the synagogue I usually attend, everyone at Darchei Noam receives their own Aliyah, they are not called up in a group. Over a hundred people are called up and the same part is read over and over again. I was in one of the first batches to get called up. They told me I would have the fourth Aliyah and gave me a playing card with the number four on it. I stared at that number four with so much fear and joy; I could hardly contain my excitement. After what seemed like an eternity I was finally called up. “Yamod…” said the Gabbai. “ Sarah bat Zvi Jonatan v’ Chava Leah”, came out of my mouth. It came out of my mouth so fast that the Gabbai had to say, “What?” ““ Sarah bat Zvi Jonatan v’ Chava Leah.” I said it a bit slower, regaining my composure. TheGabbai finally understanding sang out, “Sarah bat Zvi Jonatan v’ Chava Leah, rive’ee.”
I walked up to the Torah. In that moment I had realized that I hadn’t seen a Torah up this close in over twelve years. I came up and they handed me a cloth. I stared at this piece of cloth and thought, “What am I supposed to do with this thing.” The Gabbai hurriedly told me to kiss the cloth and then put the cloth on the Torah, "...right here". Then, I said the blessings. I sang them loud and clear, like I was a Barmitvah boy having his first Aliyah, except I sang it in tune and my voice didn’t crack. Then someone read the portion. I don’t even remember what he sounded like. I just remembered that my Aliyah ended with the word “Yisrael” What an appropriate word. My last name is Israelsohn and in that split second I knew what I had done was right. I knew that this Torah, this moment, was meant for me. I knew that I had 'gotten' my simcha back. After that I kissed the cloth a second time, read theblessing and I was done. As I came off the Bimah someone said to me “Yasher Koach” just like everyone else. I was a part of Bnei’Yisrael.
The rest of the day was a blur, I was on such a high. The only other moment I remember was when my brother was called up for his Aliyah. He strutted up there like so many times before, so at ease, so relaxed, and slowly he said his name, “Daniel Baruch ben Zvi Jonatan.” The name struck me, not his name but my father’s name- Zvi Jonatan. I had given my father and my mother an honour, something neither of them had received from me since I was eleven. Saying their names, I realized, became the greatest simcha of all.
What we need to do to put back the simcha in Simchat Torah is to include everyone. God gave the Torah to theenitre Jewish nation and the entire Jewish nation should be a part of that celebration. I hope my experience is a call to all women who sit on the sidelines year after year on Simchat Torah with empty hearts wanting to get into thegame, to find their simcha.